Money
Astrakhan
Vacancies per 1 000 residents: 3.2 times more
Which city is bigger, Makhachkala or Astrakhan? Makhachkala is bigger by population: 622,091 residents vs 465,990 in Astrakhan, 33% more. Data: Makhachkala as of January 1, 2024, Astrakhan as of January 1, 2025.
The figure under each section is a score out of 100 among all cities. There is no overall total: choose a profile, and the sections that matter for it will come first.
Astrakhan
Vacancies per 1 000 residents: 3.2 times more
Astrakhan
Living space per resident: 1.5 times more
Makhachkala
Days below zero: 14 vs 65
Astrakhan
Homes near a major road (300 m): 26% vs 72%
Astrakhan
Kindergarten places per child: 1.7 times more
Makhachkala
Cafes per 1 000 residents: 1.7 times more
To have the same left after rent for a one-bedroom, utilities and a basket of goods, in Astrakhan you need 63,100 ₽. With a salary of 67,100 ₽, in Makhachkala you’d have 13,100 ₽ left, in Astrakhan 17,000 ₽.
Rent is the median of one-bedroom listings; utilities are a typical bill for a one-bedroom; the basket of goods and services is regional. What’s left from each city’s median salary is in the table below, in the row “Left from the median salary”.
A dot is the city’s place among all Russian cities. Makhachkala Astrakhan
Ratings from 1 to 5 by people who live or have lived in the city (Makhachkala: 3 people, Astrakhan: 14 people). These are opinions, not statistics: they show how the city feels from the inside.
| Criterion | Makhachkala | Astrakhan |
|---|---|---|
| Atmosphere | ||
| Feels like home | ||
| Beautiful city | ||
| Clean streets | ||
| Culture and events | ||
| Big city | ||
| Money and housing | ||
| Affordable living | ||
| Easy to rent a home | ||
| Good place to buy a home | ||
| Good housing | ||
| Climate and nature | ||
| Mild winter | ||
| Mild summer | ||
| Sea nearby | ||
| Clean air | ||
| Nature around | ||
| Ski slopes nearby | ||
| Everyday life | ||
| Food and restaurants | ||
| Good coffee | ||
| Everything within walking distance | ||
| Public transport | ||
| Easy by car | ||
| Services and delivery | ||
| Easy to fly out | ||
| Safety | ||
| Safe streets | ||
| People and language | ||
| Attitude to newcomers | ||
| International community | ||
| People from home nearby | ||
| Health and kids | ||
| Healthcare | ||
| Childbirth and babies | ||
| Schools and universities | ||
| Work | ||
| IT and startups | ||
| Local job market | ||
| City on your CV | ||
| Convenient time zone | ||
| Internet and coworkings | ||
Colors as in the People’s ranking: reddish is bad, green is good; a pale cell means only one rating so far; bold is the best in the row. Lived there? Rate Makhachkala or Astrakhan on all criteria at once.
| Period | Makhachkala | Astrakhan |
|---|---|---|
| January | +2.5 °C | −2.3 °C |
| February | +2.8 °C | −1.3 °C |
| March | +6.5 °C | +4.3 °C |
| April | +12.4 °C | +13.0 °C |
| May | +17.3 °C | +19.0 °C |
| June | +23.6 °C | +24.7 °C |
| July | +26.2 °C | +27.1 °C |
| August | +25.3 °C | +25.9 °C |
| September | +20.1 °C | +18.5 °C |
| October | +14.7 °C | +11.5 °C |
| November | +8.5 °C | +4.3 °C |
| December | +4.2 °C | −1.2 °C |
| Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Makhachkala | +2.5 °C | +2.8 °C | +6.5 °C | +12.4 °C | +17.3 °C | +23.6 °C | +26.2 °C | +25.3 °C | +20.1 °C | +14.7 °C | +8.5 °C | +4.2 °C |
| Astrakhan | −2.3 °C | −1.3 °C | +4.3 °C | +13.0 °C | +19.0 °C | +24.7 °C | +27.1 °C | +25.9 °C | +18.5 °C | +11.5 °C | +4.3 °C | −1.2 °C |
Warmer: Makhachkala: January, February, March, September, October, November, December; Astrakhan: April, May, June, July, August.
| Indicator | MakhachkalaRepublic of Dagestan | AstrakhanAstrakhan Oblast |
|---|---|---|
| Topic scores, 0–100the score is the share of cities that do worse: 10 means worse than 90% of cities | ||
| Work and salaries | 18 | 34 — better |
| Housing | 17 | 58 — better |
| Cost of living | 61 — better | 56 |
| Climate | 98 — better | 79 |
| Environment and industrial zones | 3 | 89 — better |
| Nature and greenery | 21 | 34 — better |
| Road safety | — | 18 |
| Healthcare | 60 | 96 — better |
| Children and schools | 27 | 33 — better |
| Transport | 11 | 22 — better |
| Leisure and culture | 90 — better | 77 |
| Household and communications | 59 — better | 7 |
| Study and first job | 75 — better | 69 |
| Road to Moscow | 53 | 62 — better |
| Money and work | ||
| Median salary in job listings, ₽/mo | 67,100 — better139th of 272 · vacancies in October 2026 | 56,600237–243rd of 272 · vacancies in October 2026 |
| Average accrued salary at large and medium-sized organizations, ₽/mo | 63,9002025 | 74,1002025 |
| Average gross salary, ₽/mo | 50,500145th of 171 · 2023 | 56,900 — better119th of 171 · 2023 |
| One-room flat rent, median, ₽/mo | 30,000110–124th of 168 · listings for October 2026 | 25,000 — better59–87th of 168 · listings for October 2026 |
| Two-room flat rent, median, ₽/mo | 36,000117–120th of 181 · listings for October 2026 | 30,000 — better65–91st of 181 · listings for October 2026 |
| Left from the median salary after rent for a 1-room flat, utilities, and a basket of goods, ₽/mo | 13,100 — better81st of 168 · listings for October 2026 | 6,500138th of 168 · listings for October 2026 |
| Vacancies per 1 000 residents | 1.7214th of 223 · vacancies in October 2026 | 5.4 — better112th of 223 · vacancies in October 2026 |
| Share of vacancies offering remote work, % | 6.3 — better7th of 139 · vacancies in October 2026 | 5.514th of 139 · vacancies in October 2026 |
| Share of vacancies requiring no work experience, % | 36.1231st of 272 · vacancies in October 2026 | 47.7 — better83rd of 272 · vacancies in October 2026 |
| Unemployment, %regional | 10.92025 | 2.2 — better2025 |
| Fixed basket of goods and services, ₽/moregional | 21,9002025 | 21,600 — better2025 |
| Baskets of goods and services per median salaryregional | 3.06 — bettervacancies in October 2026 | 2.62vacancies in October 2026 |
| Housing | ||
| Median price per m² in apartment sale listings, ₽/m² | 119,900132nd of 251 · listings for October 2026 | 88,500 — better52nd of 251 · listings for October 2026 |
| Resale housing, price per m², ₽/m²regional, official statistics | 90,0002024 | 83,600 — better2024 |
| New builds, price per m², ₽/m²regional, official statistics | 89,400 — better2024 | 137,1002024 |
| Square meters of housing per year’s salary, m² | 6.7135th of 251 · October 2026 | 7.7 — better86th of 251 · October 2026 |
| Housing construction per 1 000 residents, m² | 513104th of 166 · 2023 | 534 — better98th of 166 · 2023 |
| Living space per resident, m² | 20.3139th of 148 · 2023 | 31.4 — better27–29th of 148 · 2023 |
| Family and children | ||
| Daycare places per child aged 1–6 | 0.46160th of 162 · 2023 | 0.80 — better102nd of 162 · 2023 |
| Students on the afternoon shift, %regional | 30.42024 | 22.0 — better2024 |
| Homes within 500 m of a school, % | 81124th of 267 · September 2026 | 81121st of 267 · September 2026 |
| Homes within 500 m of a kindergarten, % | 84 — better124th of 267 · September 2026 | 79167th of 267 · September 2026 |
| Homes within 200 m of a playground, % | 12243rd of 267 · September 2026 | 23 — better211th of 267 · September 2026 |
| Healthcare | ||
| Doctors per 10 000 residents | 66.671st of 173 · 2023 | 102.3 — better11th of 173 · 2023 |
| Outpatient clinics and their departments per 10 000 residents | 0.9169th of 252 · registry as of September 2026 | 1.6 — better46th of 252 · registry as of September 2026 |
| Homes within 1 km of a polyclinic or hospital, % | 93 — better46th of 267 · September 2026 | 87116th of 267 · September 2026 |
| Life expectancy, yearsregional | 79.9 — better2023 | 72.22023 |
| Climate | ||
| Average January temperature, °C | +2.5 — better10–11th of 267 · on average for 2016–2025 | −2.357th of 267 · on average for 2016–2025 |
| Average July temperature, °C | +26.2on average for 2016–2025 | +27.1on average for 2016–2025 |
| Days with a mean daily temperature below zero, days | 14 — better5–6th of 267 · on average for 2016–2025 | 6557th of 267 · on average for 2016–2025 |
| Days hotter than +30 °C, days | 39.7 — better227–228th of 267 · on average for 2016–2025 | 72.9265th of 267 · on average for 2016–2025 |
| Share of sunlight reaching the ground, % | 4949–50th of 272 · on average for 2016–2025 | 50 — better34th of 272 · on average for 2016–2025 |
| Sunny days per year, days | 65on average for 2016–2025 | 84on average for 2016–2025 |
| Daylight hours on December 21, h | 9.0 — better4th of 272 · by the city's latitude | 8.653rd of 272 · by the city's latitude |
| Annual precipitation, mm | 415on average for 2016–2025 | 242on average for 2016–2025 |
| Environment | ||
| Apartments within 2 km of a major industrial zone, % | 9149th of 256 · September 2026 | 0 — bettersame in 129 of 256 · September 2026 |
| Homes within 300 m of a major road, % | 72254th of 256 · September 2026 | 26 — better139th of 256 · September 2026 |
| Homes within 1 km of a dump or landfill, % | 0.0same in 165 of 256 · September 2026 | 0.0same in 165 of 256 · September 2026 |
| Homes within 1 km of a combined heat and power plant or thermal power plant, % | 0.0 — bettersame in 178 of 256 · September 2026 | 3.1216th of 256 · September 2026 |
| Air emissions per resident, kg/yearregional | 3 — better2024 | 932024 |
| Greenery and water | ||
| Homes within 500 m of a park or public garden, % | 67 — better105th of 267 · September 2026 | 66107th of 267 · September 2026 |
| Parks and public gardens per resident, m² | 3231st of 252 · September 2026 | 3230th of 252 · September 2026 |
| Green space within city limits, % | 50 — better206th of 272 · photo 2021 | 35253rd of 272 · photo 2021 |
| Homes within 1 km of water, % | 44148th of 267 · September 2026 | 84 — better28th of 267 · September 2026 |
| City | ||
| Universities and branches | 13 — better15–19th of 197 · admission 2024 | 928–35th of 197 · admission 2024 |
| Homes within 300 m of a bus stop, % | 52253rd of 267 · September 2026 | 62 — better234th of 267 · September 2026 |
| Bike lanes per km² of city area, km/km² | 0.00183rd of 267 · September 2026 | 0.01 — better161st of 267 · September 2026 |
| Homes within 300 m of a grocery store, % | 88 — better110th of 267 · September 2026 | 63248th of 267 · September 2026 |
| Homes within 500 m of a café, % | 95 — better11th of 267 · September 2026 | 67184th of 267 · September 2026 |
| Cafes and restaurants per 1 000 residents | 0.93 — better99th of 247 · September 2026 | 0.54193rd of 247 · September 2026 |
| Cultural institutions per 100 000 residents | 8.0248th of 252 · registry as of September 2026 | 17.4 — better181st of 252 · registry as of September 2026 |
| Households with internet, %regional | 92.92024 | 92.92024 |
| Homes with hot water, %regional | 61.12024 | 67.0 — better2024 |
| Roads | ||
| Injury crashes per 10 000 residents over 12 months | 6.6 — betterNovember 2025 — October 2026 | 13.1142nd of 161 · November 2025 — October 2026 |
| Road traffic deaths per 100 000 residents | 4.4on average for 2021–2025 | 4.3 — better64th of 161 · on average for 2021–2025 |
| Population | ||
| Population, people | 622,091as of January 1, 2024 | 465,990as of January 1, 2025 |
| Net migration per 1 000 residents | −4.82023 | −5.32023 |
Every number has its source and period in the tooltip · How we calculate
Page data: updated · Report an error