RU

Where have you lived?

Cities where you live now or used to live. Years are optional. The site will stop asking “do you live here?”.

Sign in

No password. Sign-in lets you write a review, mark things helpful, and save favorite cities and your ranking.

or via messenger

The bot will ask you to press “Start” — after that the site lets you in. We never show your email or phone number to others.

Makhachkala vs Astrakhan: where is better to live

622 thousand · January +2° · salary 67,100 ₽ · about the city
⇄
466 thousand · January −2° · salary 56,600 ₽ · about the city
+ third city

Which city is bigger, Makhachkala or Astrakhan? Makhachkala is bigger by population: 622,091 residents vs 465,990 in Astrakhan, 33% more. Data: Makhachkala as of January 1, 2024, Astrakhan as of January 1, 2025.

Which is better, by section

The figure under each section is a score out of 100 among all cities. There is no overall total: choose a profile, and the sections that matter for it will come first.

Money

Astrakhan

Vacancies per 1 000 residents: 3.2 times more

Housing

Astrakhan

Living space per resident: 1.5 times more

Climate

Makhachkala

Days below zero: 14 vs 65

Environment and greenery

Astrakhan

Homes near a major road (300 m): 26% vs 72%

Family and healthcare

Astrakhan

Kindergarten places per child: 1.7 times more

Transport and leisure

Makhachkala

Cafes per 1 000 residents: 1.7 times more

Money in rubles

To have the same left after rent for a one-bedroom, utilities and a basket of goods, in Astrakhan you need 63,100 ₽. With a salary of 67,100 ₽, in Makhachkala you’d have 13,100 ₽ left, in Astrakhan 17,000 ₽.

Rent is the median of one-bedroom listings; utilities are a typical bill for a one-bedroom; the basket of goods and services is regional. What’s left from each city’s median salary is in the table below, in the row “Left from the median salary”.

Where the difference is biggest

A dot is the city’s place among all Russian cities. Makhachkala Astrakhan

  • Pollution: 2024 vs. 2021dirtiercleanerAstrakhan betterRoshydromet yearbook on urban air pollution · 2024 vs. 2021
  • Dust in the air5.3 MAC (max allowable concentration)0.5 MAC (max allowable concentration)Astrakhan 10.6 times lessRoshydromet yearbook on urban air pollution · 2025
  • Day at a kindergarten116 ₽249 ₽Makhachkala 53% cheaperRosstat, average prices · September 2026
  • Home internet, per month978 ₽594 ₽Astrakhan 39% cheaperRosstat, average prices · September 2026
  • Living space per resident20.3 m²31.4 m²Astrakhan 1.5 times moreRosstat · 2023
  • Pool, month3,809 ₽1,883 ₽Astrakhan 51% cheaperRosstat, average prices · September 2026
  • Best university in the city: Unified State Exam score77.062.1Makhachkala betterMinistry of Science and Higher Education university monitoring · admission 2024
  • Nitrogen dioxide in the air2.1 MAC (max allowable concentration)0.6 MAC (max allowable concentration)Astrakhan 3.5 times lessRosstat · 2025
  • Homes with a café within 500 m95%67%Makhachkala betterOpenStreetMap and the building registry · September 2026
  • Specialist doctor appointment1,895 ₽815 ₽Astrakhan 57% cheaperRosstat, average prices · September 2026

What people say

Ratings from 1 to 5 by people who live or have lived in the city (Makhachkala: 3 people, Astrakhan: 14 people). These are opinions, not statistics: they show how the city feels from the inside.

CriterionMakhachkalaAstrakhan
Atmosphere
Feels like home
Beautiful city
Clean streets
Culture and events
Big city
Money and housing
Affordable living
Easy to rent a home
Good place to buy a home
Good housing
Climate and nature
Mild winter
Mild summer
Sea nearby
Clean air
Nature around
Ski slopes nearby
Everyday life
Food and restaurants
Good coffee
Everything within walking distance
Public transport
Easy by car
Services and delivery
Easy to fly out
Safety
Safe streets
People and language
Attitude to newcomers
International community
People from home nearby
Health and kids
Healthcare
Childbirth and babies
Schools and universities
Work
IT and startups
Local job market
City on your CV
Convenient time zone
Internet and coworkings

Colors as in the People’s ranking: reddish is bad, green is good; a pale cell means only one rating so far; bold is the best in the row. Lived there? Rate Makhachkala or Astrakhan on all criteria at once.

Climate on one chart

Source
Average temperature: Makhachkala and Astrakhan
PeriodMakhachkalaAstrakhan
January+2.5 °C−2.3 °C
February+2.8 °C−1.3 °C
March+6.5 °C+4.3 °C
April+12.4 °C+13.0 °C
May+17.3 °C+19.0 °C
June+23.6 °C+24.7 °C
July+26.2 °C+27.1 °C
August+25.3 °C+25.9 °C
September+20.1 °C+18.5 °C
October+14.7 °C+11.5 °C
November+8.5 °C+4.3 °C
December+4.2 °C−1.2 °C
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Makhachkala
+2+3+7+12+17+24+26+25+20+15+9+4
Astrakhan
−2−1+4+13+19+25+27+26+19+12+4−1
Average temperature by month
JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
Makhachkala+2.5 °C+2.8 °C+6.5 °C+12.4 °C+17.3 °C+23.6 °C+26.2 °C+25.3 °C+20.1 °C+14.7 °C+8.5 °C+4.2 °C
Astrakhan−2.3 °C−1.3 °C+4.3 °C+13.0 °C+19.0 °C+24.7 °C+27.1 °C+25.9 °C+18.5 °C+11.5 °C+4.3 °C−1.2 °C

Warmer: Makhachkala: January, February, March, September, October, November, December; Astrakhan: April, May, June, July, August.

Housing

Rent a one-bedroom, ₽/mo
Makhachkala30,000Astrakhan25,000
Rent a two-bedroom, ₽/mo
Makhachkala36,000Astrakhan30,000
Price per m² in listings, ₽
Makhachkala119,900Astrakhan88,500
Square meters per year’s salary
Makhachkala6.7Astrakhan7.7

All indicators side by side

a dot marks the best value in the row
IndicatorMakhachkalaRepublic of DagestanAstrakhanAstrakhan Oblast
Topic scores, 0–100the score is the share of cities that do worse: 10 means worse than 90% of cities
Work and salaries1834 — better
Housing1758 — better
Cost of living61 — better56
Climate98 — better79
Environment and industrial zones389 — better
Nature and greenery2134 — better
Road safety—18
Healthcare6096 — better
Children and schools2733 — better
Transport1122 — better
Leisure and culture90 — better77
Household and communications59 — better7
Study and first job75 — better69
Road to Moscow5362 — better
Money and work
Median salary in job listings, ₽/mo67,100 — better139th of 272 · vacancies in October 202656,600237–243rd of 272 · vacancies in October 2026
Average accrued salary at large and medium-sized organizations, ₽/mo63,900202574,1002025
Average gross salary, ₽/mo50,500145th of 171 · 202356,900 — better119th of 171 · 2023
One-room flat rent, median, ₽/mo30,000110–124th of 168 · listings for October 202625,000 — better59–87th of 168 · listings for October 2026
Two-room flat rent, median, ₽/mo36,000117–120th of 181 · listings for October 202630,000 — better65–91st of 181 · listings for October 2026
Left from the median salary after rent for a 1-room flat, utilities, and a basket of goods, ₽/mo13,100 — better81st of 168 · listings for October 20266,500138th of 168 · listings for October 2026
Vacancies per 1 000 residents1.7214th of 223 · vacancies in October 20265.4 — better112th of 223 · vacancies in October 2026
Share of vacancies offering remote work, %6.3 — better7th of 139 · vacancies in October 20265.514th of 139 · vacancies in October 2026
Share of vacancies requiring no work experience, %36.1231st of 272 · vacancies in October 202647.7 — better83rd of 272 · vacancies in October 2026
Unemployment, %regional10.920252.2 — better2025
Fixed basket of goods and services, ₽/moregional21,900202521,600 — better2025
Baskets of goods and services per median salaryregional3.06 — bettervacancies in October 20262.62vacancies in October 2026
Housing
Median price per m² in apartment sale listings, ₽/m²119,900132nd of 251 · listings for October 202688,500 — better52nd of 251 · listings for October 2026
Resale housing, price per m², ₽/m²regional, official statistics90,000202483,600 — better2024
New builds, price per m², ₽/m²regional, official statistics89,400 — better2024137,1002024
Square meters of housing per year’s salary, m²6.7135th of 251 · October 20267.7 — better86th of 251 · October 2026
Housing construction per 1 000 residents, m²513104th of 166 · 2023534 — better98th of 166 · 2023
Living space per resident, m²20.3139th of 148 · 202331.4 — better27–29th of 148 · 2023
Family and children
Daycare places per child aged 1–60.46160th of 162 · 20230.80 — better102nd of 162 · 2023
Students on the afternoon shift, %regional30.4202422.0 — better2024
Homes within 500 m of a school, %81124th of 267 · September 202681121st of 267 · September 2026
Homes within 500 m of a kindergarten, %84 — better124th of 267 · September 202679167th of 267 · September 2026
Homes within 200 m of a playground, %12243rd of 267 · September 202623 — better211th of 267 · September 2026
Healthcare
Doctors per 10 000 residents66.671st of 173 · 2023102.3 — better11th of 173 · 2023
Outpatient clinics and their departments per 10 000 residents0.9169th of 252 · registry as of September 20261.6 — better46th of 252 · registry as of September 2026
Homes within 1 km of a polyclinic or hospital, %93 — better46th of 267 · September 202687116th of 267 · September 2026
Life expectancy, yearsregional79.9 — better202372.22023
Climate
Average January temperature, °C+2.5 — better10–11th of 267 · on average for 2016–2025−2.357th of 267 · on average for 2016–2025
Average July temperature, °C+26.2on average for 2016–2025+27.1on average for 2016–2025
Days with a mean daily temperature below zero, days14 — better5–6th of 267 · on average for 2016–20256557th of 267 · on average for 2016–2025
Days hotter than +30 °C, days39.7 — better227–228th of 267 · on average for 2016–202572.9265th of 267 · on average for 2016–2025
Share of sunlight reaching the ground, %4949–50th of 272 · on average for 2016–202550 — better34th of 272 · on average for 2016–2025
Sunny days per year, days65on average for 2016–202584on average for 2016–2025
Daylight hours on December 21, h9.0 — better4th of 272 · by the city's latitude8.653rd of 272 · by the city's latitude
Annual precipitation, mm415on average for 2016–2025242on average for 2016–2025
Environment
Apartments within 2 km of a major industrial zone, %9149th of 256 · September 20260 — bettersame in 129 of 256 · September 2026
Homes within 300 m of a major road, %72254th of 256 · September 202626 — better139th of 256 · September 2026
Homes within 1 km of a dump or landfill, %0.0same in 165 of 256 · September 20260.0same in 165 of 256 · September 2026
Homes within 1 km of a combined heat and power plant or thermal power plant, %0.0 — bettersame in 178 of 256 · September 20263.1216th of 256 · September 2026
Air emissions per resident, kg/yearregional3 — better2024932024
Greenery and water
Homes within 500 m of a park or public garden, %67 — better105th of 267 · September 202666107th of 267 · September 2026
Parks and public gardens per resident, m²3231st of 252 · September 20263230th of 252 · September 2026
Green space within city limits, %50 — better206th of 272 · photo 202135253rd of 272 · photo 2021
Homes within 1 km of water, %44148th of 267 · September 202684 — better28th of 267 · September 2026
City
Universities and branches13 — better15–19th of 197 · admission 2024928–35th of 197 · admission 2024
Homes within 300 m of a bus stop, %52253rd of 267 · September 202662 — better234th of 267 · September 2026
Bike lanes per km² of city area, km/km²0.00183rd of 267 · September 20260.01 — better161st of 267 · September 2026
Homes within 300 m of a grocery store, %88 — better110th of 267 · September 202663248th of 267 · September 2026
Homes within 500 m of a café, %95 — better11th of 267 · September 202667184th of 267 · September 2026
Cafes and restaurants per 1 000 residents0.93 — better99th of 247 · September 20260.54193rd of 247 · September 2026
Cultural institutions per 100 000 residents8.0248th of 252 · registry as of September 202617.4 — better181st of 252 · registry as of September 2026
Households with internet, %regional92.9202492.92024
Homes with hot water, %regional61.1202467.0 — better2024
Roads
Injury crashes per 10 000 residents over 12 months6.6 — betterNovember 2025 — October 202613.1142nd of 161 · November 2025 — October 2026
Road traffic deaths per 100 000 residents4.4on average for 2021–20254.3 — better64th of 161 · on average for 2021–2025
Population
Population, people622,091as of January 1, 2024465,990as of January 1, 2025
Net migration per 1 000 residents−4.82023−5.32023

More comparisons

Every number has its source and period in the tooltip · How we calculate

Page data: updated · Report an error

Top